When the Cutie Mark Crusaders go on a quest to find some ingredients for their next culinary masterpiece, they seek out the wise mare on the edge of ponyville for information.
Information they'll not soon be forgetting.
Sorry for the day-late comic. Procrastination got the better of me!
Ponies belong to our supreme pony overlords Comic belongs to me Do not re-use unless you have permission from me.
Okay, first of all, the whole idea is just brilliant and hilarious. The fact that the crusaders messed up just by slightly miswording their problem shows how much simple things can turn into huge misunderstandings, and the reaction each character has to Fluttershy's "explanation" just highlights the whole fiasco.
In addition, I think the art was really well done, and each character's reactions were perfectly done. It all serves to highlight the story and show how much good intentions can go wrong.
Overall, this is an excellent piece of work, and I would love to see more comics from you.
Because of how old and used this joke is ill put you in a fairly average originality rating, that and the copying of the shows style. I do realize it's in the vector category so i draw half a star for that and 1 1/2 star because of the joke.
The Technique almost perfect however, i draw half a star, because i am not satisfied with Fluttershy's expression on the third panel, i would imagine her to have a more awkward look and be a lot more repulsed by a the task this embarrassing. The face of the CMC is also all the same expression wich is quite fun, but i would imagine them to have around the same reaction mentally but different expressions (but that is all really just nitpicking, it really does not matter that much, in other words no removal of stars because of great vectorization.)
The impact is an average since this has indeed been done before however you have the ability to make great comics and i look forward too seeing more of it.
They went to Fluttershy to get some information or attain some Birds and Bees. Fluttershy misunderstood and thought they wanted the "Talk" about the "Birds and The Bees" which is a popular metaphorical story to explain where babies come from. The fillies are left traumatised.
Well logically she would be the one of the Mane 6 who you can actually see knowing all this stuff. She treats animals, cares for them and is around them a LOT, so I can actually see how she would be more knowledgeable (at least scientifically rather than emotionally) about the facts.
Okay, first of all, the whole idea is just brilliant and hilarious. The fact that the crusaders messed up just by slightly miswording their problem shows how much simple things can turn into huge misunderstandings, and the reaction each character has to Fluttershy's "explanation" just highlights the whole fiasco.
In addition, I think the art was really well done, and each character's reactions were perfectly done. It all serves to highlight the story and show how much good intentions can go wrong.
Overall, this is an excellent piece of work, and I would love to see more comics from you.
The Technique almost perfect however, i draw half a star, because i am not satisfied with Fluttershy's expression on the third panel, i would imagine her to have a more awkward look and be a lot more repulsed by a the task this embarrassing. The face of the CMC is also all the same expression wich is quite fun, but i would imagine them to have around the same reaction mentally but different expressions (but that is all really just nitpicking, it really does not matter that much, in other words no removal of stars because of great vectorization.)
The impact is an average since this has indeed been done before however you have the ability to make great comics and i look forward too seeing more of it.
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.